Panther Softball Announces Sophomores Moving on to Four-Year Programs

Pictured left to right: Emmalee Bell, Peyton Clemensen, Ella Gargstang, Hailey Sheaffer, and Mylee Taylor.
Pictured left to right: Emmalee Bell, Peyton Clemensen, Ella Gargstang, Hailey Sheaffer, and Mylee Taylor.

The Ellsworth Community College softball program will see five sophomores move on to four-year institutions following the 2026 season, continuing a consistent pattern of player advancement as the Panthers wrap up a 23–38 campaign.

Head coach Nate Forsyth said supporting student-athletes as they transition into the next stage of their journey remains an important part of the program's everyday mission.

"It's extremely important that everybody we bring in does move on," Forsyth said. "Some continue playing, some move on academically, and we're here to help them get to that next level however we can."

Forsyth emphasized that the process is individualized, with athletes taking the lead in their recruiting journeys while the coaching staff provides guidance, communication, and support when needed.

"When we start the process, I really want them to reach out to schools and show their interest," he said. "Then we step in and help support them through conversations with coaches and the recruiting process."

This year's group of sophomores has secured opportunities at the next level, with destinations spanning Division I, NAIA, and four-year private institutions.

Emmalee Bell, Mount Mercy University

Bell, a first baseman and designated hitter, will also join Mount Mercy after a strong developmental period at Ellsworth. Bell made an immediate impact in the Panther lineup during her time in Iowa Falls, providing a steady offensive presence in the middle of the order and handling duties at first base. A former education major who transitioned into social work, Bell said her experience in the program helped shape her long-term goals.

Peyton Clemensen, Clarke University

A pitcher from Vinton, Iowa, Peyton will continue both her academic and athletic career at Clarke. Clemensen was one of Ellsworth's most consistent arms in the circle this season. She provided valuable innings in a variety of game situations and was relied upon to complete against strong conference competition. In addition to pitching, Peyton was used as a pinch runner and provided excellent speed on the bases for the panthers. A Vinton, Iowa native, she cited Ellsworth's close-knit environment as a key factor in her development and growth as a student-athlete.

Ella Gargstang, Mount Mercy University

An outfielder headed to Mount Mercy, Ella will continue her career while pursuing a degree in pre-physical therapy and exercise science. Garstang was a dependable leadoff hitter who helped set the tone at the plate and provided reliability in run-scoring opportunities. She said her time at Ellsworth helped her grow both on the field and in the classroom, highlighting the friendships and lessons learned from coaches and professors.

Hailey Sheaffer, Mount Marty University

Schaefer, a pitcher and utility player from Kansas, will continue her softball career in South Dakota. Schaefer contributed as a versatile right-handed pitcher and utility option for the Panthers, providing depth in the pitching staff while also bringing athletic flexibility across multiple positions. Her role at Ellsworth reflected her ability to support the team in different situations and compete in a variety of game roles throughout the season. She pointed to the memories and relationships built at Ellsworth as the most meaningful part of her experience, adding that she looks forward to competing at the next level.

Mylee Taylor, University of Maryland Eastern Shore

Taylor, a versatile catcher and outfielder from Colorado, will compete at the DI level. Known for her adaptability and defensive presence, she also brings strong experience, leadership and toughness as a catcher. She credited Ellsworth with helping ease her transition away from home, noting the welcoming team culture and strong connections built within the program.

The Panthers conclude the 2026 season at 23–38, with a roster that once again produced multiple opportunities for athletes to continue their careers at four-year programs.

As Forsyth noted, the focus remains unchanged. "We just try to help them take that next step," he said. "That's what this program is built to do. These five sophomores have made a tremendous impact on our program and will be greatly missed both on and off the field. We're proud of the dedication they've shown to our program and excited to watch them begin the next chapter of their journey."